HB 2973: Regarding venue for legal actions against the West Virginia Secondary School Activities Commission - West Virginia

hb2973 hfa hornby 4-1 _2 adopted.htm → hb2973 hfat akers 4-1 adopted.htm · 6 edits

MODERATE

The bill's title was amended to replace Delegate Hornby's amendment with Delegate Akers' amendment. The original amendment focused on venue restrictions for Kanawha County lawsuits involving the West Virginia Secondary School Activities Commission, while the new amendment provides a comprehensive description of the bill's purpose including legal action procedures, claim notice requirements, tolling provisions, injunctive relief exceptions, and venue clarification.

Scope change

The scope of the bill's description was expanded from a specific venue restriction for Kanawha County to a broader overview covering multiple procedural aspects including claim notice requirements, tolling provisions, injunctive relief exceptions, and venue clarification for all actions involving the West Virginia Secondary School Activities Commission.

SCOPE

The amendment text was replaced entirely, changing from a specific venue restriction for Kanawha County lawsuits to a comprehensive bill title description covering multiple procedural requirements.

VENUE

The specific venue restriction requiring Kanawha County lawsuits involving the WV Secondary School Activities Commission to be prosecuted outside Kanawha County was removed.

New description added indicating the bill clarifies venue where actions may be brought and prosecuted.

REQUIREMENT

New description added indicating the bill requires 30 days' notice of claims and establishes procedures for providing such notice.

New description added indicating the bill provides exceptions for certain claims involving injunctive relief.

TIMELINE

New description added indicating the bill provides for tolling of claims.

Committee Substitute for the Committee Substitute → hb2973 hfa hornby 4-1 _2 adopted.htm · 1 edit

MINOR

This amendment modifies HB 2973 to change where certain legal suits involving the West Virginia Secondary School Activities Commission must be filed. The change redirects jurisdiction for specific lawsuits from Kanawha County to any other county in the state, affecting how disputes are handled.

Scope change

The bill's scope regarding venue for legal actions involving the commission was modified to exclude Kanawha County for specific student-related lawsuits.

ENFORCEMENT

Added a provision stating that suits brought by or on behalf of students enrolled in Kanawha County schools, or by the Kanawha County Board of Education, involving schools in Kanawha County where the commission is a defendant, must be filed in any county other than Kanawha County.

Committee Substitute → Committee Substitute for the Committee Substitute · 4 edits

MODERATE

This bill revision expands the notice requirements for legal actions against the West Virginia Secondary School Activities Commission, adds tolling provisions for the statute of limitations, creates an exception for urgent injunctive relief cases, and clarifies the filing location for lawsuits.

Scope change

The scope of the bill was expanded from a single notice requirement to a comprehensive framework including notice procedures, tolling mechanisms, exceptions for emergency relief, and jurisdictional clarity.

REQUIREMENT

Added specific requirements for written notice via certified mail with return receipt requested, detailing exactly who must receive notice and the required content.

Modified the original notice requirement by breaking it into four detailed subdivisions with specific procedural steps and timing rules.

TIMELINE

Added provisions tolling the statute of limitations for 30 days from the date of mailing and receipt of the required notice.

ENFORCEMENT

Added an exception allowing immediate legal action without notice in cases seeking injunctive relief where irreparable harm would occur if delayed.

Engrossed Committee Substitute for the Committee Substitute → Committee Substitute · 3 edits

MINOR

The bill text was converted from a formal legislative document format to a website display format, with the substantive legal content remaining identical. The only meaningful change is the addition of a new subsection (f) regarding preparatory athletic programs and a new subsection (g) establishing jurisdiction and notice requirements for legal actions against the WVSSAC.

Scope change

The bill's scope expanded to include specific provisions for preparatory athletic programs and established a mandatory filing location and notice period for legal actions involving the WVSSAC.

ENFORCEMENT

Added new subsection (g) requiring all legal actions against the WVSSAC to be filed in Kanawha County Circuit Court with a 30-day notice to the commission, State Board of Education, and Attorney General.

SCOPE

Added new subsection (f) allowing preparatory athletic programs to compete nationally as nonparticipating members if they pay member fees, but prohibiting them from competing against member schools in regular season or state championship events.

TECHNICAL

Changed document format from formal legislative text to website display format with navigation links and headers, but retained all original legal content.

Introduced Version → Engrossed Committee Substitute for the Committee Substitute · 5 edits · Apr 2, 2025

MODERATE

This bill significantly changes HB 2973 by shifting its focus from clarifying where lawsuits can be filed to establishing new legal procedures for claims against the West Virginia Secondary School Activities Commission. The engrossed version adds requirements for 30-day notice of claims, tolling of statutes of limitations, and specific rules about which courts have jurisdiction over lawsuits involving the Commission.

Scope change

The bill's scope expanded from primarily clarifying venue for lawsuits to including new claim notification procedures and jurisdiction rules for the West Virginia Secondary School Activities Commission.

REQUIREMENT

Added requirement that parties must provide written notice by certified mail to the Commission, State Board, and Attorney General at least 30 days before filing a lawsuit.

TIMELINE

Established a 30-day tolling period for statutes of limitations when proper notice is provided.

ENFORCEMENT

Added jurisdiction rules requiring suits against the Commission to be filed in Kanawha County, with exceptions for Kanawha County schools suing the Commission.

EXCEPTIONS

Created an exception for injunctive relief cases where irreparable harm would occur if the 30-day notice requirement was enforced.

SCOPE

Changed the bill's primary purpose from clarifying filing locations to establishing claim procedures and jurisdiction rules.

Regarding venue for legal actions against the West Virginia Secondary School Activities Commission

What changed between versions

How they voted

Actions timeline

Sponsors