SB 445: Regulatory Reform Act of 2026. - North Carolina

Ratified → SL 2026-59 · 5 edits

MODERATE

The transition from Ratified Bill to Session Law 2026-59 includes several substantive amendments: a vesting right duration was extended from two years to five years, a fine for subsequent violations was increased from $1,000-$3,000 to $3,000-$5,000, the alternate building inspection method was expanded to cover home power installations, and a mining public hearing deadline was clarified. The remaining changes are formatting updates (page headers, version number, and the governor's signature block with approval date of August 11, 2026).

TIMELINE

The duration of a vested right for a site-specific vesting plan was extended from two years to five years, giving developers a longer period of regulatory stability before local zoning changes can affect their project.

The deadline for requesting a public hearing on a new or modified mining operation was clarified to run from either the issuance of the notice or the receipt of the application by the Department, whichever is later, potentially extending the window for community input.

ENFORCEMENT

The fine for a subsequent violation (within three years of a prior violation) was increased from a range of $1,000 to $3,000 to a range of $3,000 to $5,000, strengthening the penalty for repeat offenders.

SCOPE

The alternate inspection method for building components or elements was expanded to include home power installations, allowing them to be inspected under the simplified process when designed and sealed by a licensed architect or professional engineer.

TECHNICAL

A minor text correction was made to the flag display provision, fixing an apparent typographical error where 'States' was duplicated or misplaced after 'United States unless:'.

Edition 5 → Ratified · 12 edits

MAJOR

SB 445 was substantially restructured between Edition 5 and ratification. The bill dropped numerous provisions on fisheries reporting, Arbor Week, water theft penalties, LPG emergency refills, underground storage tank discharge timelines, college admissions test surveys, PESA scholarship expansion, school capital fund prioritization, and site-specific vesting plan duration changes. In their place, the ratified version introduces new provisions on de novo judicial review of agency rule interpretations, an exemption for certain nonconforming signs from state preemption, protection against property covenants restricting flag display, and alignment of the manufactured home definition with federal law.

Scope change

The bill's scope narrowed significantly. Edition 5 was a broad omnibus covering environment and natural resources, education, and business/development reforms across multiple parts. The ratified version is reorganized around 'Business and Administrative Reforms' as Part I, dropping the environmental and most education provisions while adding new administrative law review standards, property rights protections, and definitional conforming changes.

ENFORCEMENT

Administrative law judges must now apply 'traditional de novo review' when interpreting state rules and regulations in contested cases. Courts reviewing final agency decisions use a de novo standard for constitutional violations, excess of authority, unlawful procedure, and other errors of law, while using the whole record standard for substantial evidence and arbitrary/capricious claims.

The increase in civil penalties for water theft (from $5,000 minimum to $10,000 minimum for water pipe connections) was removed.

SCOPE

Local government ordinances regulating on-premises advertising signs are exempt from state preemption under G.S. 160D-912.1 if they included an amortization period of 10 or more years for nonconforming signs and the compliance date expired on or before July 1, 2024.

The repeal of the 2023 fisheries harvest reporting requirement (G.S. 113-170.3(d)-(g)) was removed from the bill.

REQUIREMENT

Property covenants (declarations) can no longer restrict display of the U.S. or North Carolina flag up to four feet by six feet unless the restriction uses specific enumerated terms (for restrictions registered before October 1, 2005) or contains a boldface capital-letter statement on the first page explicitly stating it regulates flag display (for restrictions registered on or after that date). The protection applies only to exclusively owned property, not common areas.

DEFINITION

The state definition of 'manufactured home' in three statutes (G.S. 25-9-102(53), G.S. 143-143.9(6), and G.S. 143-145(7)) is conformed to the federal definition in 42 U.S.C. section 5402(6), replacing prior state-specific definitions with a reference to the federal standard.

TIMELINE

The change moving Arbor Week from March to November was removed.

The five-year deadline for the Environmental Management Commission to determine risk levels of noncommercial underground storage tank discharges was removed.

The increase in site-specific vesting plan duration from two years to five years (and maximum from five to eight years) was removed.

ELIGIBILITY

The provisions allowing liquefied petroleum gas refills during qualifying emergencies, including detailed conditions for emergency suppliers and liability protections, were removed.

The expansion of PESA scholarship allowable expenses to include one-to-one classroom aide services and tuition reimbursement for non-compliant schools was removed.

FISCAL

The change to the Needs-Based Public School Capital Fund prioritization criteria (shifting from county-level to project-level consideration of prior grant receipt) was removed.

Edition 4 → Edition 5 · 3 edits

MINOR

The bill text was updated from Edition 4 to Edition 5, reflecting its progression through the legislative process with new committee approval dates and an official engrossed status. The substantive legal content regarding gas regulations and penalties remains identical to the previous version, with no changes to scope, definitions, or enforcement mechanisms.

TIMELINE

Added 'Fifth Edition Engrossed 6/3/26' to the header to indicate the bill's current legislative status and date.

TECHNICAL

Updated the bill version number from S445-v-4 to S445-v-5 in the footer.

Reordered the line numbers in the legislative text to reflect the new edition's pagination.

Edition 3 → Edition 4 · 4 edits

MODERATE

The bill was updated to reflect the 2026 legislative session and includes three substantive policy changes: extending a study deadline for water transfers, moving Arbor Week from March to November, and increasing civil penalties for water theft. The most significant change is the increase in the civil penalty for water theft from $5,000 to $10,000, which strengthens enforcement against utility tampering.

Scope change

The bill's scope was expanded to include a new provision allowing liquefied petroleum gas refills during emergencies, and the effective date for the water theft penalty increase was set to December 1, 2026.

TIMELINE

The deadline for the Collaboratory's study on surface water transfers was extended from March 1, 2027, to August 1, 2028, providing more time for analysis before new transfer certificates can be issued.

REQUIREMENT

Arbor Week was officially moved from March to November, changing the designated week in the state statute to contain November 15 instead of March 15.

ENFORCEMENT

The civil penalty for water theft was increased from $5,000 to $10,000 (or triple damages, whichever is greater) to deter utility tampering and increase accountability.

ELIGIBILITY

A new provision was added to allow emergency suppliers to provide liquefied petroleum gas refills during declared emergencies, ensuring consumers have access to fuel when normal supply chains are disrupted.

Edition 2 → Edition 3 · 5 edits

MODERATE

The bill was completely rewritten to shift its focus from emergency hospital relief to broad regulatory reforms for North Carolina citizens. The new version repeals outdated fisheries reporting rules, extends a deadline for studying water transfer impacts, moves Arbor Week to November, and increases penalties for water theft.

Scope change

The bill's scope changed from a narrow focus on healthcare emergency waivers to a wide range of environmental and consumer protection reforms.

SCOPE

All provisions regarding automatic adoption of federal healthcare waivers and hospital disaster relief were removed.

REQUIREMENT

New requirements were added to repeal specific fisheries harvest reporting rules.

Arbor Week was moved from March to November.

TIMELINE

A deadline for a study on surface water transfers was extended, and a moratorium on new water transfer certificates was established until 2028.

ENFORCEMENT

Civil penalties for water theft were increased.

Edition 1 → Edition 2 · 3 edits

MINOR

The bill removed the requirement for hospitals to notify the Division of Health Service Regulation within 72 hours when utilizing preapproved waivers during emergencies. It also simplified the language regarding automatic federal waivers, removing the specific condition that state waivers must reduce regulatory requirements to be consistent with federal law, thereby granting the Division broader discretion to modify rules during federal emergencies.

Scope change

The bill's scope regarding emergency procedures was narrowed by removing the mandatory 72-hour notification requirement for hospitals, while the scope of the Division's authority to modify rules during federal emergencies was expanded.

REQUIREMENT

Eliminated the 72-hour notification deadline for hospitals to inform the Division when preapproved waivers are activated.

Removed the constraint requiring state rule modifications to 'reduce regulatory requirements' to match federal waivers, allowing the Division more flexibility in how it adjusts rules during federal emergencies.

TECHNICAL

Cleaned up formatting errors in the header and removed redundant spacing and page markers.

A1: ABR-77-V-4 → Edition 1 · 4 edits

MODERATE

This bill transforms from a procedural amendment document into a complete legislative act titled 'Reg. Relief for Hospitals in Disaster Zones.' It establishes a new legal mechanism allowing state hospital rules to be automatically waived or modified to align with federal waivers issued during emergencies, ensuring North Carolina hospitals can immediately comply with federal disaster relief directives without waiting for separate state approvals.

Scope change

The bill's scope expanded from a generic amendment template to a specific, standalone law applicable to all hospitals in North Carolina during declared emergencies or public health crises.

REQUIREMENT

Added a new requirement for automatic alignment: state hospital rules must automatically be modified or waived to match any temporary federal waivers issued by HHS or CMS under the Social Security Act.

TIMELINE

Established that state waivers matching federal rules must remain in effect at least until the corresponding federal waiver expires.

DEFINITION

Formally defined 'emergency management agency' by referencing the existing state statute G.S. 166A-19.3.

TECHNICAL

Removed all internal amendment markup, page references, and procedural notes (e.g., 'Amendment No. __________') to convert the document into a finalized bill text.

Filed → A1: ABR-77-V-4 · 3 edits

MINOR

The bill was amended to remove the automatic adoption of federal healthcare waivers for hospitals during disasters. Instead, the amendment replaced the hospital relief provisions with unrelated text regarding student surveys for college admissions and site-specific vesting plans for land development.

Scope change

The bill's scope shifted entirely from healthcare emergency relief to education and land use regulations.

SCOPE

Eliminated the provision requiring state hospitals to automatically adopt federal waivers for bed capacity and rules during emergencies.

REQUIREMENT

Added requirements for public schools to allow students to complete college admissions surveys with parental consent.

Added rules governing site-specific vesting plans for land development approvals.

Regulatory Reform Act of 2026.

What changed between versions

How they voted

Actions timeline

Sponsors