A 9251 New York Assembly · 2025 Regular Session

Relates to prediction markets

New York State Bill A 9251 prohibits prediction market platforms from allowing New York residents to trade on specific types of events, including political elections, athletic competitions, deaths, and catastrophic incidents such as wars or natural disasters. The legislation defines these restricted categories in detail and explicitly bans "unlawful commodity" markets where the underlying activity violates state or federal law. Platforms that violate these restrictions face civil penalties ranging from $10,000 to $50,000 per violation, with fines increasing to twice the profits derived or $50,000 for prohibited market types. Additionally, providers who continue operating after a court order to cease operations in the state incur a penalty of $1 million per day, and the Attorney General is granted authority to enforce these rules and issue necessary regulations.
Bill status in committee 1 of 4 stages cleared
Introduction
Nov 2025
Committee Review
Floor Vote
Governor
Introduced Nov 7, 2025 Last action Aug 17, 2026
Maddy AI version diff · 2 comparisons

What changed between versions

A9251A A9251B · 9 edits
MAJOR
The bill was substantially narrowed and refocused. Version A contained a comprehensive regulatory framework for prediction markets including age restrictions, advertising rules, at-risk trading protections, settlement source requirements, credit card prohibitions, market-making restrictions, insider trading rules, and a parallel amendment to the racing law. Version B strips all of that away, replacing it with a much leaner bill centered on legislative findings condemning certain prediction market products (specifically parlay-replicating contracts) and a short list of prohibited market types. The effective date was also shortened from one year to 90 days.
SCOPE

The entire amendment to the Racing, Pari-Mutuel Wagering and Breeding Law (old Section 2, adding new section 913) was deleted. That provision had prohibited licensed gaming entities from offering prediction markets and imposed fines of $10,000-$100,000 per violation with license revocation.

A new Section 1 containing legislative findings was added. It states that certain prediction market platforms have 'strayed far from bona fide commodities' and specifically calls out multi-leg combination contracts that replicate sportsbook parlays, noting retail participants lost hundreds of millions of dollars in the current year alone. The findings declare the act is enacted under police power to protect consumers.

The list of prohibited markets changed: 'security markets' (betting on publicly traded company prices) was removed from the prohibited list, and 'unlawful commodity markets' was added. The prohibition language was broadened from merely 'open a speculative position' to 'open, hold, trade, or settle a speculative position, or otherwise participate.'

REQUIREMENT

Age restrictions (minimum 21), exclusions from participation (self-excluded persons, insiders, employees), settlement source disclosure requirements, at-risk trading measures (deposit limits, self-exclusion tools, HOPE NY hotline display, employee training), advertising restrictions (no targeting minors, no push notifications for bonuses, no 'risk-free' language), credit card and gift certificate prohibitions, market-making restrictions (banning gaming companies as liquidity providers), and insider trading/market manipulation detection requirements were all removed.

DEFINITION

The definition of 'prediction market' was simplified by removing the 'in a bid-ask format' requirement, and the separate 'bid-ask format' definition was deleted entirely. A new definition of 'unlawful commodity' was added, covering any commodity offering that violates state or federal law (including the Commodity Exchange Act), with determination by controlling judicial decision or reasonable AG interpretation in absence of one.

The 'political market' definition was narrowed: references to federal elections and the actions of the federal government, its agencies, employees, officers, or leaders were removed. Only New York statewide and municipal elections, and state/municipal government actions, remain covered.

The 'prediction market platform' exclusion was broadened. Previously it excluded platforms that were licensed, would be required to be licensed, or were prohibited under the racing law. Now it excludes any platform (or portion thereof) to the extent activity is conducted pursuant to a license issued under the racing law or other state law.

ENFORCEMENT

The penalties section now explicitly states the attorney general has independent enforcement authority that is 'not contingent upon, or limited by, the action or inaction of the commodity futures trading commission.' The enhanced penalty (greater of 2x profits or $50,000) now applies only to violations of the prohibited markets section rather than also covering the removed exclusions and market-making sections.

TIMELINE

The effective date was shortened from one year after enactment to 90 days after enactment.

Floor votes

How they voted

No floor votes recorded yet.
Full legislative history

Actions timeline

Total actions
6
Key actions
4
Committee
2
Amendments
4
Aug 17, 2026
Lower · Passed
PRINT NUMBER 9251B
lower
Aug 17, 2026
Lower · Passed
AMEND (T) AND RECOMMIT TO CONSUMER AFFAIRS AND PROTECTION
lower
Mar 10, 2026
Lower · Passed
PRINT NUMBER 9251A
lower
Mar 10, 2026
Lower · Passed
AMEND (T) AND RECOMMIT TO CONSUMER AFFAIRS AND PROTECTION
lower
Jan 7, 2026
Committee
REFERRED TO CONSUMER AFFAIRS AND PROTECTION
lower
Nov 7, 2025
Committee
REFERRED TO CONSUMER AFFAIRS AND PROTECTION
lower
1 primary · 3 co-sponsors

Sponsors