A 4992 New York Assembly · 2025 Regular Session

Clarifies the standard for when a practice has a discriminatory effect

Summary
Clarifies the standard for intentional discrimination or retaliation claims by requiring a person or persons prove that an unlawful motivation was a motivating factor and not "the sole motivating factor" or a "but-for cause" of the challenged treatment.
Bill status in committee 1 of 4 stages cleared
Introduction
Feb 2025
Committee Review
Floor Vote
Governor
Introduced Feb 10, 2025 Last action Jan 7, 2026
Maddy AI version diff · 1 comparison

What changed between versions

A4992 A4992A · 5 edits
MODERATE
This bill changes the legal standard for proving employment discrimination in New York. Previously, plaintiffs had to prove discrimination was the sole cause of adverse treatment. Now, they can prove discrimination by showing a practice had a discriminatory effect, even if there was no discriminatory intent.
Scope change
The bill expands the scope of discrimination claims to include cases where practices have discriminatory effects, rather than requiring proof of discriminatory intent.
REQUIREMENT

Added a new subdivision 5-a to Section 296 of the executive law establishing that unlawful discriminatory practices can be proven by discriminatory effect alone.

Established a two-part burden of proof: complainants must first show discriminatory effect, then respondents must prove the practice was necessary for legitimate interests and no less discriminatory alternative existed.

Clarified that demonstrating legally sufficient justification cannot be used as a defense against intentional discrimination claims, preserving existing protections.

DEFINITION

Defined 'discriminatory effect' as practices that actually or predictably result in disparate impact on protected groups including race, creed, gender, disability, and other characteristics.

TIMELINE

Changed the bill's effective date language to apply to all cases occurring on and after the effective date, rather than taking effect immediately.

Floor votes

How they voted

No floor votes recorded yet.
Full legislative history

Actions timeline

Total actions
5
Key actions
2
Committee
2
Amendments
3
Jan 7, 2026
Committee
REFERRED TO GOVERNMENTAL OPERATIONS
lower
May 29, 2025
Introduced
AMEND BY RESTORING TO ORIGINAL PRINT 4992
lower
May 21, 2025
Lower · Passed
PRINT NUMBER 4992A
lower
May 21, 2025
Lower · Passed
AMEND (T) AND RECOMMIT TO GOVERNMENTAL OPERATIONS
lower
Feb 10, 2025
Committee
REFERRED TO GOVERNMENTAL OPERATIONS
lower
1 primary · 5 co-sponsors

Sponsors