HB 710: Generally revise laws related to the judiciary - Montana

HB0710_X(2).pdf → HB0710_X(3).pdf · 5 edits

MODERATE

The bill was amended to remove several substantive provisions regarding the Judicial Standards Commission, including the allocation of its administrative duties to the Department of Justice, a prohibition on judges serving as the commission's presiding officer, and specific rules about the burden of proof for constitutional challenges. Additionally, the effective date was changed from 'on passage' to 'immediate,' and the bill's title was updated to reflect these deletions.

Scope change

The bill's scope was narrowed by removing provisions that altered the structure and administrative operations of the Judicial Standards Commission.

REQUIREMENT

Removed the requirement to allocate the Judicial Standards Commission to the Department of Justice for administrative purposes.

Removed the prohibition preventing a judge on the Judicial Standards Commission from serving as its presiding officer.

Removed the specific establishment of the burden of proof for claims that a legislative act violates the Montana Constitution.

TIMELINE

Changed the effective date of the act from 'on passage' to 'immediate'.

SCOPE

Updated the bill title to accurately reflect the removal of the deleted provisions.

HB0710_2(15).pdf → HB0710_X.pdf · 6 edits

MODERATE

This bill revises laws regarding the judiciary by empowering judges to issue subpoenas for Internet Crimes Against Children Task Force officers, reorganizing the Judicial Standards Commission under the Department of Justice, and establishing a higher burden of proof for challenging state laws in court. These changes aim to improve investigative capabilities for child exploitation cases, clarify administrative oversight of judicial commissions, and strengthen constitutional review standards.

Scope change

The bill expands the scope of judicial authority to issue subpoenas specifically for Internet Crimes Against Children investigations and modifies the administrative allocation of the Judicial Standards Commission.

ENFORCEMENT

Added authority for Supreme Court justices and district court judges to issue subpoenas to compel testimony and records from Internet Crimes Against Children Task Force officers during investigations of sexual exploitation of minors.

Changed the burden of proof for challenging legislative acts as unconstitutional from 'preponderance of evidence' to 'beyond a reasonable doubt'.

DEFINITION

Defined 'internet crimes against children task force officer' as a state peace officer assigned to a federally recognized task force.

REQUIREMENT

Modified the Judicial Standards Commission to be allocated to the Department of Justice for administrative purposes only, while retaining its independent functional authority.

Prohibited judges on the Judicial Standards Commission from serving as the commission's presiding officer.

TIMELINE

Removed specific effective dates for the act, changing it to be effective upon passage and approval.

HB0710_2(6).pdf → HB0710_2(7).pdf · 3 edits

MINOR

The bill makes minor formatting adjustments to section titles and corrects a grammatical error in the text describing the Supreme Court's authority. These changes do not alter the substantive law, scope, or applicability of the bill.

TECHNICAL

Changed the capitalization of the word 'allocation' in the section title from all caps to lowercase.

Added the phrase 'this state' to clarify the jurisdiction in the section title.

Removed the redundant word 'may' from the sentence describing the Supreme Court's power to regulate legal procedures.

HB0710_2(3).pdf → HB0710_2(4).pdf · 5 edits

MODERATE

The bill amends the Montana Judicial Standards Commission by clarifying its composition to include two non-attorney citizens, establishing staggered four-year terms, and ensuring the commission operates independently from the Department of Justice. It also corrects grammatical errors in the rules of court section and standardizes the effective dates for the act.

Scope change

The scope of the bill's substantive changes is limited to the internal structure and administrative independence of the Judicial Standards Commission; the rules of court section was modified only for grammatical correction.

REQUIREMENT

The composition of the Judicial Standards Commission was clarified to explicitly include two citizens who are not attorneys or judges, alongside two district court judges and one attorney.

Members of the Judicial Standards Commission are now required to serve staggered four-year terms.

ENFORCEMENT

The bill mandates that the Judicial Standards Commission exercise its functions independently of the Department of Justice without approval or control from that department.

TECHNICAL

The rules of court section was corrected to remove redundant and grammatically incorrect words like 'may' and 'the'.

TIMELINE

The effective dates for the act were standardized, setting the main provisions for October 1, 2025, and specific sections for passage and approval or July 1, 2025.

HB0710_1(5).pdf → HB0710_2.pdf · 4 edits

MODERATE

The bill text was updated with new page headers and footers, but the substantive legal content regarding subpoena powers and judicial standards was altered by inserting numerous grammatical errors and typos (e.g., 'power to may', 'upon on') and reordering the effective dates section to include a new subsection.

Scope change

The scope of the bill's applicability remains unchanged; the changes are technical and editorial rather than policy-based.

TECHNICAL

Page headers and footers were changed to reflect a new version number (HB0710.2) and include the year 2025.

The effective dates section was restructured to add a new subsection (3) regarding the effective date of Section 2, which was previously listed as subsection (2).

Multiple lines containing legal text were corrupted with inserted words like 'to may', 'upon on', and 'Such The', creating grammatical errors that do not affect the actual legal meaning.

The order of items in the list of required records for subpoenas was shifted, though the items themselves remain the same.

LC2938.pdf → HB0710_1.pdf · 1 edit

MINOR

The bill was renumbered from LC 2938 to HB 710 and the list of sponsors was updated to reflect the current legislators. The substantive legal text regarding subpoenas for internet crimes, judicial commission allocation, and constitutional review standards remains unchanged.

Scope change

None; the bill's scope and applicability are identical to the previous version.

TECHNICAL

The bill number changed from LC 2938 to HB 710, and the list of sponsors was updated to include new names while removing old ones.

Generally revise laws related to the judiciary

What changed between versions

How they voted

Actions timeline

Sponsors