HB 371: Ban mRNA vaccinations in Montana for humans - Montana

HB0371_1(5).pdf → HB0371_2.pdf · 3 edits

MINOR

The bill was amended to narrow its scope by changing the title and text to specifically prohibit only 'gene-based vaccines for infectious diseases' rather than all gene-based vaccines. This change adds a specific exemption for gene therapy products used to treat cancer or genetic disorders, which were previously included in the ban. The amendment also clarifies the definition of the prohibited vaccines to explicitly list mRNA and related technologies while excluding therapeutic gene treatments.

Scope change

The bill's scope was narrowed from a broad ban on all gene-based vaccines to a specific ban only on those used for infectious diseases, explicitly exempting gene therapies for cancer and genetic disorders.

SCOPE

The bill title and text were changed to restrict the ban to 'gene-based vaccines for infectious diseases' instead of all gene-based vaccines.

DEFINITION

A new definition was added clarifying that 'gene-based vaccine for infectious diseases' includes mRNA and related technologies but explicitly excludes gene therapy products used to treat cancer or genetic disorders.

ELIGIBILITY

The exemption for gene therapies treating cancer or genetic disorders was added, meaning these treatments are no longer subject to the ban.

HB0371 Legal Review Note.pdf → HB0371_1(2).pdf · 5 edits

MODERATE

The document changed from a legal review note analyzing potential constitutional conflicts to the actual text of the bill. The bill prohibits administering gene-based vaccines (including mRNA, modified mRNA, self-amplifying mRNA, and DNA vaccines) to humans in Montana and imposes a $500 fine per violation.

Scope change

The scope changed from a legal analysis of a proposed ban to the enacted text of the ban itself, which applies to all humans within the state of Montana.

REQUIREMENT

Added a prohibition on providing or administering gene-based vaccines to any human within Montana.

ENFORCEMENT

Added a penalty provision making violators guilty of a misdemeanor with a $500 fine per incident.

Added a requirement for the Montana Department of Labor and Industry licensure board to review the license of any licensed person who violates the ban.

DEFINITION

Added a definition of 'gene-based vaccine' to include mRNA, modified mRNA, self-amplifying mRNA, and DNA technology.

TECHNICAL

Removed the legal review commentary regarding Supremacy Clause conflicts and the requestor's arguments about Emergency Use Authorization.

HB0371_1(1).pdf → HB0371 Legal Review Note.pdf · 4 edits

MODERATE

The document was transformed from a draft legislative bill into a legal review note containing constitutional analysis and policy arguments. The original bill text, which prohibited gene-based vaccines and set penalties, was removed and replaced with explanatory text discussing federal preemption and the FDA's Emergency Use Authorization.

Scope change

The bill's scope is no longer active; it has been replaced by a document analyzing the bill's potential conflicts with federal law.

REQUIREMENT

Removed the original prohibition against administering gene-based vaccines and the associated misdemeanor fine.

Added a legal review section analyzing potential conflicts with the U.S. Constitution's Supremacy Clause and federal FDA regulations.

Added policy arguments supporting the ban based on the Tenth Amendment and critiques of the FDA's Emergency Use Authorization process.

DEFINITION

Removed the specific definition of 'gene-based vaccine' and the codification instruction for Title 45.

LC1463.pdf → HB0371_1.pdf · 3 edits

MINOR

The bill was renumbered from LC 1463 to HB 371.1 and the list of sponsors was updated to include new names. The core text of the bill, which prohibits gene-based vaccines and outlines penalties, remains substantively unchanged, though minor formatting adjustments were made to the definition section.

TECHNICAL

The bill number changed from LC 1463 to HB 371.1, indicating a procedural update in the legislative process.

The list of bill sponsors was updated to include additional legislators (G. Kmetz, L. Schubert, K. Love, T. Sharp, R. Gregg, E. Tillemann, T. Manzella, D. Emrich, S. Gist, R. Marshall, J. Schillinger, L. Deming, and S. Maness).

Minor formatting adjustments were made to the definition of 'gene-based vaccine' to align with standard bill formatting conventions.

Ban mRNA vaccinations in Montana for humans

What changed between versions

How they voted

Actions timeline

Sponsors